In the evolving world of precision manufacturing, Intuitive Surgical stands at the forefront of innovation. Based in the San Francisco Bay Area, the company has transformed modern healthcare with robotic-assisted, minimally invasive surgery systems. These advanced technologies enable surgeons to perform complex procedures with unprecedented precision—reducing complications, improving recovery times, and redefining what’s possible in human surgery.
But innovation at Intuitive Surgical isn’t limited to the operating room. Behind the scenes, its finance and manufacturing teams are equally committed to advancing efficiency and transparency—especially when it comes to cost management. This case study explores one such example: how the company used SAP’s standard functionality in a creative way to meet a unique business requirement for manufacturing cost analysis using a COGS (Cost of Goods Sold) split.
This blog is based on a presentation by Anind Debnath at the SAP Controlling Conference.
The Business Challenge
Shortly after joining Intuitive Surgical, the presenter was faced with an unusual request from the CFO: “In my financials, I want to see the manufacturing cost broken down by cost components—material, labor, and overhead. And I also want to see the absorption or capitalization of those costs, similarly broken down.”
While analyzing cost components is standard practice, extending that same visibility to the absorption side—how costs are capitalized into inventory—was not. SAP provides standard variance analysis and cost component reporting, but not in the precise structure the CFO wanted to see on the income statement.
In short, the request was:
- Break down manufacturing variances by material, labor, and overhead.
- Reflect that same breakdown in absorption and inventory capitalization.
This went beyond typical reporting boundaries and required a creative approach within SAP’s framework.
The Analytical Approach
The challenge prompted an exploration into SAP’s COGS split functionality—a standard feature designed to separate cost of goods sold by component categories. Traditionally, COGS split is used for sales-side reporting, not for manufacturing cost absorption. However, by “repurposing” it, the team aimed to achieve the desired level of visibility for manufacturing costs.
The first attempts involved explaining standard variance analysis options and reporting tools to finance. But business leaders were adamant—they wanted to see the data integrated directly into the financial statement, not in separate reports.
So, the consultant took a bold step: to leverage (or, as he humorously called it, “misuse”) the COGS split functionality on the production side. This allowed costs to be decomposed into their components at the time of absorption, effectively mimicking what the CFO had asked for.
Technical Insights and Adjustments
The process required careful handling of subassemblies—semi-finished products that include their own labor and overhead costs. When these subassemblies were rolled up into finished goods, misalignments initially occurred, leading to distorted variances (for example, negative labor or overhead).
By adjusting the treatment of subassembly consumption—removing embedded labor and overhead from the material layer and redistributing them correctly—the variance analysis finally balanced out. The result: a complete manufacturing cost picture by component, consistent across production, WIP, and COGS reporting.
Broader Implications: Big Data and Analytics
This project also highlighted a broader shift in enterprise data architecture. With tools like Snowflake and Tableau, the Intuitive analytics team could replicate SAP tables in near real-time and perform sophisticated, multi-dimensional analysis without traditional system limitations.
This convergence of ERP precision and big data flexibility means that business users no longer need to navigate multiple subledgers or transactions—they can analyze costs, variances, and profitability in one integrated data environment.
Key Takeaway
What started as an unconventional accounting request became a powerful demonstration of how standard SAP functionality can be creatively adapted to meet evolving business needs. By applying the COGS split in a new context, Intuitive Surgical bridged the gap between operational costing and financial reporting—enhancing transparency, decision-making, and analytics readiness in the process.
This blog is based on the presentation by Anind Debnath: “Case Study: Insights to Manufacturing Cost Analysis with COGS Split” from the SAP Controlling Conference.
To access the full session and other in-depth SAP Controlling topics, sign up for our membership here.
